New on my other blogs

"Gandhi is dead, Who is now Mahatmaji?"
Solar scam reveals decadent polity and sociery
A Dalit poet writing in English, based in Kerala
Foreword to Media Tides on Kerala Coast
Teacher seeks V.S. Achuthanandan's intervention to end harassment by partymen


31 August, 2008

Human Rights organizations call for tangible affirmative action in Orissa

The following is the text of a statement issued jointly by the Asian Human Rights Organization, Hong Kong, the National Human Rights Campaign on Dalit Human Rights, India, and the Dalit Solidarity Network, Denmark, on the Orissa developments:

The current wave of violence in Orissa, India is not surprising. After all, Orissa is a state in India ruled by the Biju Janata Dal (BJD). The BJD has remained in power with the support of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), a Hindu fundamentalist political force operating in India. As a result, the BJD has subscribed to the larger Hindutwa agenda propagated by the BJP and its political allies like the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) and the Bajrang Dal.

The ongoing violence in Orissa, though has been principally portrayed as a Hindu - Christian issue is in fact an act of attempted subjugation by the dominant caste upon the Dalits. Orissa like the rest of India is in abstract a society where the political economy is defined by the capacity of a dominant caste to arbitrarily subordinate the rest of its members especially the Dalits and the tribal communities. Social order is the excuse for this arbitrary domination; caste and religious practices its scepter.

In a society dominated by caste, the concept of individual and individual freedom does not exist. Caste is the language of unchallenged ascendancy of one group over the other. Subordination of the lower ranks is a rule than an expectation. The possibility of change is ruled out by awarding sempiternal birthrights to the privileged and anchoring perpetual subjugation and bondage to the underprivileged.

The essence of Hindu religion is this adamantine de rigueur of life. Vedas and the ultimate Sanadana Dharma are the pharisaic justifications offered to this slavery. The concept of Hindutwa, advocated by the BJP, VHP, BJD and its allies, in principle is the legitimisation sought for the attempted third revival of the Hindu religion and its necromantic practices.

The statements issued by these fundamentalist forces and their antagonism against other religions are transuding with hate speech, calling for the use of brute force to suppress any challenge to the dominant caste supremacy. The violence in Orissa used to suppress the Dalit empowerment in this context is not a surprise.

Orissa is a state in India with an estimated population of 32 million. About 84 percent of this population lives in villages and one third of them do not own any substantial extent of land other than their homestead. An estimated 28 percent of this population are Dalits. Until recently, this large Dalit population suffered unchallengeable exploitation by the dominant castes.

In the past 10 years there has been a massive social movement in Orissa empowering the Dalit communities. Empowered Dalits who declared themselves as socially equal in status started levelling the centuries old uneven social balance in the state.

Education and the knowledge gained through exposure emboldened the Dalits to fight and raise their voice against dominant caste supremacy. Discrimination and slavery were no more tolerated by the Dalits. Obviously, the dominant caste groups led by the VHP and its allies had to take drastic actions to suppress this awakening.

New avenues opened up for the Dalits by delinking themselves from the Hindu caste system and its pretentious hegemony has been an eyesore for the fundamentalist Hindu political forces in the state. The VHP that leads the fundamentalist Hindu forces in Orissa started forcibly closing all possible exits for the Dalits to escape from the furnace of the Hindu caste system. For this, they employed the wisdom they had gained from the annihilation of Buddhism in India.

Naturally for the Dalits the practice of any other religion other than Hinduism was declared a taboo. Regional and state-wide campaigns were organised by the VHP to counter the Dalit empowerment. Sections of the Dalit communities in the state were forced to declare their subjugation to the dominant caste groups in ritualised ceremonies conducted by brute use of force and intimidation.

The state government of Orissa led by the BJD, an invisible partner of the VHP, let these 'reintegration' ceremonies happen throughout the state. The confusion, trauma and sufferings caused by this religious vandalism was exploited by the so called anti-state actors like the Maoists operating in the state. Natural calamities, extreme poverty, starvation and malnutrition also added further fire to the commotion.

The murder of a VHP leader and four of his colleagues on August 23 was only yet another excuse for the communal forces like the VHP to fan out their vendetta against the Dalits and their empowerment in the state. What is being witnessed in Orissa is the meticulous execution of a larger plan to force the Dalits back into the talons of caste based discrimination.

A state government that lets such evil to befall upon a population by its inaction shares equal responsibility like the VHP. The conspiracy of the state administration and the VHP is evident from the five days of complete inaction of the administration to take any steps to prevent the violence. The state administration must be held equally responsible for the loss of life and property, including that of the VHP cadres.

Now that the state administration has proved itself to be a silent spectator to the violence in the state, the government of India must ensure that the ongoing violence is arrested immediately. The Dalits who were forced to seek shelter and safety in the forests must be provided security to return. The government must also ensure that the victims of violence are adequately compensated.

The true test of a state in protecting and promoting democracy and pluralism is not how much these terms are mentioned in the domestic laws, but how good is the state apparatus in preventing the infringement of democratic values and how much equipped are the state mechanisms in providing redress for any violations.

The government of India, by virtue of its Constitutional mandates and the moral and legal obligations arising out of its ratification of international treaties and conventions must ensure that a state of normalcy returns to Orissa.

India by virtue of ratifying international conventions like the Convention on Civil and Political Rights, the Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination also has an obligation under the international human rights law to ensure that similar instances does not recur in the country. The international community also has a moral responsibility to urge the government of India to immediately put an end to the violence in Orissa.

It is only by such tangible affirmative action that the government of India can stand the test of commitment that it has sworn primarily to its own people and also to the protection, promotion and fulfilment of human rights and human values in the world.

# # #

About AHRC: The Asian Human Rights Commission is a regional non-governmental organisation monitoring and lobbying human rights issues in Asia. The Hong Kong-based group was founded in 1984


Anonymous said...

What is not reported is that the volience was started by Christians who killed a 89 year old Swami who is doing welface activities from 30 years.
The voilence that followed is natural reaction of the angry tribals.
The root of the problem is these missionaries who have hidden agenda to convert whole India.
They start if with innocent, gullible tribals who don’t even relate what is right or wrong.

Think what those missionaries are doing there when there is lot of poverty in Christian countries.
They are NOT doing services for already converted.But they are doing 'services' for people who are potential Convertable targets.

There are lot of lies in this report.
In India there was never a problem with lot of religions from long time.
Buddism and Hinduism existed peacefully and it is Adi Sankara Charaya who peacefully told about Hindusm and brough India back to Hindusm.
Check your facts!!

BHASKAR said...

The web enables one to comment anonymously but I wish those who wish to challenge facts and counter opinions have sufficient courage of conviction to do so openly and not under cover of anonymity.
Everyone is entitled to his views but misrepresentation of facts needs to be countered.
Media reports on the Swami's murder said he was killed by suspected Naxalites. A Naxalite group also subsequently owned responsibility for the crime.
The claim that Sankaracharya 'peacefully told about Hinduism' runs counter to Swami Vivekananda's observation that 'Sankara personally led' the hordes that attacked the Buddhist monastery at Nagarjunakonda. I may add here that Vivekananda's statement, too, is questionable. He seems to have relied upon 'Sankaravijayam', of which different versions have been in circulation for years. It is not a work of history but an eulogy. Followers' accounts of the exploits of their masters cannot be taken as literal truth.

Joseph Pulikotil said...


Very interesting and informative post!

The murderous attack on poor Christians by the VHP and Bajrang Dal should be condemned by all right thinking people because Swami Lakshmanananda was not killed by Christians.

It is a pity that even before a proper investigation was carried out, the VHP took the law into their own hands and murdered Christians.

The state government encouraged the attacks since strong measures were not taken to prevent the savagery.

Religious freedom is granted by the Constitution. Any one can follow any religion of his choice. All Christians in India were Hindus once upon a time. They converted to Christianity because they were not happy with Hinduism.

Both the VHP and Bajrang Dal should be banned immediately.

BHASKAR said...

Personally I do not favour the ban option. The basic problem in Orissa is not that criminal activities are going on but that that the state is abdicating its responsibility to check criminal activities or proving to be incapable of discharging that responsibility. This is happening in other States also. The only remedy is to mobilize public opinion and force the rulers to discharge their duty. This, of course, is easily said than done.